Some Old Comic Creator Dudes Think The New Wonder Woman Costume Is Taliban-Esque And The Result Of A “Vocal Minority”


So some comics bros said some dumb things this weekend. That’s not a rare occurrence, really; you could devote a whole blog to such things if you were so inclined. But the ridiculousness this weekend centered on Wonder Woman, and some odd responses to her new costume. Neither Erik Larsen or J. Scott Campbell like the new outfit, which I can understand. I don’t like it either. It’s their reasons for why they don’t like it that made their comments so bizarre.

Larsen, clearly offended at the new Wonder Woman costume as well as several recent outfit changes for female characters, declared on Twitter:

I’m tired of the big two placating a vocal minority at the expense of the rest of the paying audience by making more practical women outfits.

He added:

It’s weird enough when they layer more clothes on a character like Wonder Woman but Spider-Woman & Batgirl were already covered head-to-toe.

In response to the idea that these outfits are more practical, Larsen suggested that they aren’t actually practical at all, pointing to “the many athletes who participate in sports and wear considerably less.” What’s fascinating about this outrage and line of reasoning is that it seems to only apply to women. He’s not upset that male superheroes have been covered head-to-toe for 75 years now. No, he’s upset that women are getting covered up more lately, and moving from skin tight outfits to looser fitting clothes. Clearly he prefers his female characters more sexily clad.

But apparently a “vocal minority” is ruining all his fun. And by “vocal minority”, it seems that he means the flood of new women readers the comic book industry has seen over the past decade who tend to prefer female characters who look like people rather than sexed up embodiments of the male gaze. You know, all those folks who’ve responded enthusiastically to a lot of the new outfits and takes on female characters and whose excitement has led to some very solid sales and helped grow the industry. That pesky vocal minority, aka. the future of the industry that’s saving it from slowly dying from a stagnant audience.

J. Scott Campbell chimed in on Wonder Woman’s new outfit as well, writing:

I rarely comment about comic book industry matters on my personal FB page, but I gotta say, shoulder pads, especially big bulky metal ones NEVER look good on women. Everything about them is unfeminine and lacks style. No grace to this approach at all.

And on a side note, I find the continued knee-jerk reaction to internet message board critics demands to keep female heroines covered from head to toe in fabric an overreaction. She’s an Amazon Warrior, she’s NOT in the *Taliban!

First, to be fair to Campbell, the Taliban bit was a flippant, dumb joke. Nonetheless, he seems to think that there are scores of fans who want female heroes to be fully covered, and that’s just not the case. There are a lot of people who’d like female characters to be less exposed, myself among them, but there’s a whole lot of wiggle room between having everything on display and covering up a woman entirely.

Campbell went on to call Wonder Woman’s new costume “political correctness by committee” and then got irked at the angry feminists who were obviously taking everything he said the wrong way. What I find interesting is that my reaction to the costume, and the reaction of most feminist fans I know who want to see better representations of women in comics, has been generally negative. There hasn’t been much enthusiasm for it all, and those who speak positively about it seem to be coming from an angle of, “It’s nice that Wonder Woman has pants for a change, but the whole look isn’t great.” This isn’t Batgirl or Captain Marvel, whose new costumes got near universally rave reviews when they debuted (the “vocal minority” really loved those ones). The reviews for the new Wonder Woman are mixed at best, and more bad than good. I don’t know what group of people Campbell is referring to who loves this new outfit and wants to see all women fully covered.

Furthermore, the new costume is designed by David Finch, who loves to draw scantily clad women and has shown time and again that he really doesn’t care about feminism in the slightest. THAT is where the design is coming from. No fans were clamouring for it, we didn’t storm DC’s offices demanding Wonder Woman be covered. DC clearly wanted a new look for their June mini-relaunch, and this is what Finch came up with.

And the weird thing is, I agree with Larsen and Campbell that Wonder Woman’s new costume is ugly and cumbersome. I really don’t care for it. It doesn’t work for her at all, and I think that Wonder Woman is a character who doesn’t necessarily need to be fully covered. But there’s a big leap between “I don’t like this” and “It’s the fault of a vocal minority/message board critics/feminists.” Larsen and Campbell come off like they’re mad at women for making DC and Marvel take all the boobs away, which is a) ridiculous, and b) not the case at all. Sorry comics aren’t going to be as exploitive of women as they used to be, guys. Get used to it, because the “vocal minority” isn’t going away.


Tags: , , , , ,

11 Responses to “Some Old Comic Creator Dudes Think The New Wonder Woman Costume Is Taliban-Esque And The Result Of A “Vocal Minority””

  1. merryjest Says:

    There was obviously a committee behind WW’s costume. WHAT kind of committee? Hell knows. But Finch’s design of it is simply terrible- which doesn’t gel with the fact that he gave Donna Troy such a fantastic outfit that was, shockingly enough, not a bikini.

    So there is something not right at all with this costume. It does feel like Finch got handed a checklist of things to implement from a group of people who still think mullets are what the kids are wearing these days.

    • Anonymous Says:

      Maybe it was terrible on purpose so they could quickly change it back and have ‘everyone’ shut up. They get to say ‘we tried’ without actually trying at all.

  2. Cow Commando Says:

    Truth be told though, the look does bring to mind muslim track and field athletes!

  3. solsdottir Says:

    It never made sense to me that an Amazon warrior would go around in a swimsuit. But the shoulder pads look very 80s and I dont understand the blades at all. (300, anyone?)

  4. IronBerserk Says:

    I don’t mind it too much the new look. The shoulder pads really is the only major gripe I have with it. They appear too large and flashy.

    Even as a fan of WW, I never really much cared for her costume. It always felt too American and bikini like. It was the character and what she represents that mattered to me. I even liked a lot the JMS costume and it saddened me when they didn’t continue with it. People are way too attached to the past. Something tells me this won’t last.

    • Dwayne G. Says:

      Iron if you have been a fan of WW for very long you know the new costume will NOT last very long. Looking back at old WW comics going back to the mid 60’s it seems shes always “New” or “Sensational New” every few years or so. I think the real problem is DC has never really known what to do with her and this new costume is just an another example of that.

    • Nancy pike Says:

      How is it “bikini-like”? Do you even know what a bikini is? Doesn’t sound like it. As for being American, WW has always been an American heroine regardless of the nonsensical revisionism of latter days. She’s been wearing red, white, and blue since 1941.

  5. trish Says:

    Well said! 🙂

  6. DC’s “next best thing” is seriously lacking & it’s no surprise who’s missing. | Amber Unmasked Says:

    […] fight some of the creators like Erik Larsen, Brett Booth, and J. Scott Campbell who think their presentation of women is the only “right” […]

  7. Nancy pike Says:

    It’s a fugly costume. What’s wrong with Lynda Carter’s classic look? Why does WW need a new costume? What she needs is a new writer who doesn’t suck.

  8. John Sorensen Says:

    I really like the New 52 version of WW’s costume as seen in the Cliff Chiang run. It had the right mix of strength and power, it was feminine without being overly exposed or making Wonder Woman look as dopey as she did when she wore the bikini briefs that made her look more like she escaped from Baywatch, I cringe whenever I see that old costume. The skirt and alternate version she first appeared in both look great.

    The costume in the post above I don’t really care for at all. But I have not yet read the story. I think that commenting on costumes redesigns before reading the story and seeing the context is kind of pointless.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: